by Bob » 10 Jul 2010, 21:07
Shane, I share your passion for classical Arabic, Turkish, and Indian musical styles in addition, of course, to flamenco. I spent years traveling in those parts of the world and became fond of their music.
Lorette is correct that our "Información Histórica" section is a good place to start learning about flamenco history. However, learning the true history of flamenco is fraught with problems because the roots of flamenco are ancient, portions were created and evolved over long periods of time by diverse racial, political, and religious groups that spoke a variety of languages and dialects and that sometimes had, and still to this day have, strong biases, animosities, and even hatreds relative to each other. Furthermore, little written history of flamenco exists far back in time and fragmentary evidence is based mostly on information passed aurally through generations of possibly-biased family members.
I knew nothing about any of that when I first visited Spain in the 1960's and asked what I thought were simple questions that could be easily answered, such as where did the soleares, alegrias, farruca, etc., originate. I often got simple answers, but it didn't take long to discover the answers depended on who I would ask. Today, answers will vary depending on which website you visit and much of what is being written about flamenco these days is being written by people with more imagination than knowledge.
Evolution is another compounding factor. Imagine that someone played a soleares faster than usual and called it a bulerias, because it sounded "funny" at that speed. Imagine others started playing soleares fast and calling it bulerias. What would be the origin of the bulerias? Would it be the time and place where soleares was first played fast and called "funny" or would the bulerias have the same origin as the soleares? If you think the origin would be the same as the soleares, how much would the bulerias have to evolve differently over time to not be considered a soleares? If the bulerias evolved over many years to become significantly different than the soleares, at what place and time would it have a different origin and who would have been the creator?
-Bob