Castillo wrote:I don't like machine heads, because pitch changes so gradually when they are rotated. It is easier for me to tune a guitar with wooden pegs, so long as they don't bind, but the pegs on my guitar do bind occasionally and I have been wondering about I trying geared planetary tuners when I am able to afford a new guitar. Do tuning changes occur as slowly with geared planetary tuners as with machine head tuners? If so, I probably wouldn't like them.
Castillo
No, it is faster and easier and has the peg feel just smoother. The thing is you have to push in like a peg and it may not be perfect but to raise or lower a fraction only requires a gentle touch with no pushing in. Only drastic changes require the pushing on the peg while tuning. I always liked my wooden pegs a bit sticky because I had developed a special shake from tuning pianos. The trick is to be able to have a quick shake as you push to stop the peg at the precise point. This was fine in my younger days when I tuned several stringed pegged instruments (pianos, violins, violas, cellos, basses, banjos, lutes, and guitars) several times a week, but now the flamenco guitar is all I tune and the mechanical pegs are the easiest way. Here is the neat thing Castillo, if you get a new guitar with mechanical pegs and cannot master them, then it is easy to replace them with wooden pegs. Simply pull them out and put in the wooden ones. With a new price of $150 for a set, you wouldn't get hurt much as I bet a used set would sell quickly for at least half price. I changed strings today and must say nothing is easier and quicker getting to pitch and to hold tune than the mechanical pegs.